Laguna Vista and Laguna Drive
Laguna Drive and Laguna Court, with Los Arboles, Palomas and Manzano drives around them, south of Village Hall on Glengary Road. FEMA's records call it Laguna Vista Subdivision No. 1, and one of the village's two community well systems carries the Laguna Vista name, drawing from two wells over 100 feet deep. Off-water houses built from 1958 to 1972 sold for $196,000 to $370,000 from 2023 to early 2025 by township records, and Redfin shows 815 Manzano at $377,000 in September 2026. On the water, a Laguna Drive house sold for $690,000 in October 2024.
Clara Miller Park, Woodlawn and Roselawn
Clara Miller Park, the village's 13 and a half acre park off Benstein Road, with a pavilion and summer restrooms, sits beside a grid of 1960s and early 1970s houses on Woodlawn, Roselawn, Brisbane and Terry Drive, most on a fifth to half an acre. Township records show sales here from $198,000 to $390,000 between April 2023 and September 2024, and Redfin shows 2388 Woodlawn selling for $296,500 in October 2026 after listing at $325,000.
Benstein Road and the west edge
Terrapin, Tellico, Ellington and Darnell streets, Apple Orchard Lane and Avery Court, between Benstein Road and the village's west line. Building runs a little later here, from the late 1960s to 1984, and township records show sales from $230,000 to $327,000 in 2023 to early 2025. Redfin shows 2150 Benstein at $279,900 and 2363 Darnell at $247,000 in September 2026. The Census block group for this side of the village, from Laguna Vista to Delmonte Street, shows an owner median near $246,000, a typical home from 1973 and every home detached.
Spring Lake Heights and Delmonte Street
The west arm of the lake, in plats FEMA's records call Spring Lake Heights and its annex, a name that recalls Spring Lake, one of the six small lakes the 1920s dam joined. Lakefront houses on Delmonte Street built from 1970 to 1974 sold for $600,500 in May 2023, $976,000 in August 2024 and $755,624 that October. Our sample of FEMA's map puts the largest stretch of high-risk Zone A on dry village land near the west end of Delmonte, so check this end of the street on the flood map first.
Oak Island
Stuart's Oak Island formed on Dr. Howard Stuart's land when the dam raised the water, and Oak Island Drive, reached from Oakview off Glengary Road, has a village pocket park. FEMA's records list Stuart's Oak Island Subdivision among the lots where a map amendment took the house out of the high-risk zone while part of the lot stayed in. Two lakefront sales on Oak Island Drive show the range, $635,000 in June 2022 and $555,000 in August 2025.
Solano and Ventura drives
Lakefront lots near the middle of the village, where FEMA's records name the Ventura Drive plat Wooded Shores. The township recorded the village's only three sales above $1 million from April 2023 to March 2025 here: $1,575,000 for a 2013 house on Solano Drive in April 2024, $1,100,000 for a 2018 house on Ventura Drive that July and $1,324,000 for a 2016 house on Solano in February 2025. A 1960 ranch on more than an acre on Solano sold for $499,900 in March 2024. FEMA has issued four map amendments for Wooded Shores lots, three on Ventura.
Wolverine Lake Heights and Angola Street
East-side lakefront and the streets behind it, Angola, Helmsford and Glencove, in plats FEMA's records call Wolverine Lake Heights and Frischerof. Lakefront sales ran $509,000 on Helmsford Drive in 2022 and $667,500 on Angola Street in August 2025, while 1957 ranches on Glencove Road sold for $301,000 and $316,000 in 2023. Low ground around Helmsford Drive holds another patch of Zone A. The Census block group for the east half, from Oak Island to Shankin, shows an owner median near $437,000, give or take about $43,000, a typical home from 1965 and about one home in five in a building of five or more units.
Tampa Drive and the South Commerce Road shore
The northeast shore along South Commerce Road, with Tampa Drive, Payne Court, Ethel Drive and Briar Ridge. Lakefront houses sold for $565,000 on Payne Court in January 2022, $600,000 and $630,000 on South Commerce in 2024 and $605,000 for a 1971 brick ranch on Tampa in 2023. Off the water, late 1950s ranches on Ethel sold for $255,000 and $285,000 and a 2019 colonial on Briar Ridge for $470,000. Redfin shows 2622 Tampa Drive at $318,000 in September 2026.
Shankin and Penny Lake Woods
Shankin follows the southeast shore, with Wanda and Wabasso behind it. FEMA's records call several of the lakefront lots Penny Lake Woods, and the township's land study lists five lakefront sales on Shankin from $625,000 to $865,000 between 2022 and 2025. Off the water, a 1950 house on Shankin sold for $255,000 in 2024, older ranches on Wanda and Wabasso for $276,000 and $310,000, and a 1966 ranch on Shankin Court for $416,500. Redfin shows 1813 Shankin at $495,500 in September 2026.
Penny Lake Estates, Pinecrest and Sunset
The village history tells of Penny Lake, a pond at the lake's lower southeast corner until the narrow strip of land beside it was removed as shoreline homes went up. The name lives on in Penny Lake Road and in the Penny Lake Estates community well system, two wells 291 feet deep. Houses from 1967 to 1969 on Penny Lake Road, Pinecrest and Sunset drives sold for $265,000 to $315,000 in 2023 and 2024. The Census block group for the south side shows an owner median near $285,000, a typical home from 1974 and 419 of its 435 homes owner-occupied.
Wolverine Drive, Amenia Park and Dunreath
Wolverine Drive follows the south shore, and the streets behind it, Amenia, Ladd, Lucille, Adelaide and Alberton, mix houses from the 1920s to the 1990s around Amenia Park, a pocket park between Wolverine Drive and Ladd Road. Lakefront sales on Wolverine Drive ran $560,000 to $825,000 in 2023 and 2024, and a 1925 house at 600 Wolverine sold for $652,000 in June 2024 and $695,000 in August 2025. Off the water, prices went from $150,000 on Adelaide to $390,000 for a 1997 ranch on Amenia, and a 2018 colonial on Dunreath Road sold for $471,000.
Heron Hills condominiums
Attached condominiums at the northeast corner, on Heron Hills Drive and Egret, Widgeon, Golden Eye and Teal lanes, built from 2005 to 2007 by township records. Eleven sold between August 2023 and September 2024 for $220,000 to $311,000, a median of $290,000. A condo loan needs the association to pass the lender's review, so ask early for its budget, reserves and insurance. Low ground near Turtle Creek Lane is in Zone A, and the Census block group here runs well past the village line, so its figures say little about these units.