Barton Shore Drive at the Whitmore Lake Road entry
The east end of the village's longest road, which runs about 1.5 miles from the Whitmore Lake Road entry along Barton Pond. The 2020 Census counted 27 homes in the block between here and Underdown Road. Ann Arbor Township's sales study lists a house of about 6,400 square feet on 2.55 acres here at $2,000,000 in July 2023, and Redfin shows a 2.22-acre building lot on this stretch selling for $750,000 in October 2026. Village Hall sits at 199 Barton Shore Drive, beside the open fields at the southeast entry that the Maintenance Corporation owns.
Barton Shore Drive along the pond and the Boat Club
The middle stretch faces Barton Pond, the City of Ann Arbor's reservoir behind Barton Dam, which supplies about 85% of the city's drinking water. The Barton Boat Club, founded in 1937, sits at 446 Barton Shore Drive on Maintenance Corporation land, and the shore between the club and Spring Valley Road is Corporation waterfront for its shareholders. No speed boats or jet skis are allowed on the pond. The township's sales study shows a 1957 George Brigham design on this stretch, per its listing, on 1.05 acres, at $2,200,000 in May 2024.
Corrie Road and Hillspur Road
Two short spurs off Barton North Drive, about 0.28 and 0.19 miles long, on the slope above the pond. Three sales here since 2024: a Corrie Road house on 2.57 acres, by the township's record, at $1,550,000 in November 2024, a Hillspur Road house of about 3,200 square feet on 2.73 acres at $1,225,000 in June 2025, and a David Osler mid-century house on Corrie Road, 1.88 acres per its listing, at $1,249,000 in January 2026. Some homes off Corrie Road and Barton North Drive sit on private drives that the Maintenance Corporation does not maintain, so check how the driveway reaches the road.
Underdown Road
A 0.4-mile road with a short spur on the east side of the village. A 1920 house here, about 8,500 square feet on 2.18 acres, first listed at $3,000,000 in July 2024 and sold for $1,900,000 that December, per Redfin and the township's study. Its listing noted winter views of Barton Pond through the west windows, and the township's study counts it among the arm's-length sales it used to value village houses for 2026.
Barton North Drive and the country club side
The 0.9-mile road across the north of the village, with Corrie and Hillspur branching off it. In the block that takes in the Barton Hills Country Club at 730 Country Club Road, the 2020 Census counted just 12 homes on about 125 acres. A house of about 5,100 square feet on 5.14 acres sold for $1,550,000 in May 2023, and a two-bedroom ranch sold for $900,000 in November 2025 after listing at $1,200,000. A paved extension off Barton North Drive leads to the 40-acre Jan and David Esch Nature Preserve just outside the village line.
Country Club, Colliston and Forest roads
The northwest corner, where Country Club Road, about 0.7 miles inside the village, meets Colliston and Forest roads. The 2020 Census counted 15 homes across the two blocks here, on about 46 acres. A mid-century house on about 2.2 acres sold for $1,980,000 in June 2025 after listing at $2,400,000. Country Club Road continues outside the village into Ann Arbor Township, where the same street name carries a lower tax rate: the township's study lists a township parcel on Country Club Road at $1,125,000 in May 2024.
Oakdale Road, Juniper Lane and the west end
The west side, from Oakdale Road, about half a mile with a spur, and Spring Valley Road down to Juniper Lane, a short spur off Barton Shore Drive, plus a private drive west off Barton Shore Drive. At 32 homes on about 70 acres in the 2020 Census, it has the most homes per acre of any part of the village. No sale here appears in the township's study for April 2023 through December 2025, which is how rarely some Barton Hills streets see a house change hands.
Shared parks, fields and the nature preserve
The Maintenance Corporation owns three parks inside the village, among them Minoma and Cayuga, plus the fields on either side of Barton Shore Drive at the southeast entry, the waterfront by the Boat Club and the 40-acre Esch Nature Preserve beyond the northeast corner. These lands are for Corporation shareholders and their invited guests, and pets stay on leash. Shares are tied to parcels, one vote for a developed lot and half a vote for an undeveloped one, and most but not all village households hold one, so ask whether the parcel you are buying carries a share.